
Hong Kong discussion paper response · November 2026
Making agentic banking decisions contestable
A bank’s AI agent can refuse a loan because it misclassified a payment. It can also apply a rule exactly as written and leave the customer asking why the rule exists. In both cases the customer has an objection. What would let them look into it, and who has to answer?
On November 16, 2026, I sent a response to the Hong Kong Monetary Authority’s (HKMA) Discussion Paper on Agentic A.I. Governance in the Banking Sector. It recommends a practical test for customer contestability: can an affected person identify a material ground of an agent’s action, investigate it through a feasible information route, and obtain a reasoned response from someone able to act on the finding?
The discussion paper presents the HKMA’s preliminary views. It creates no new obligations and does not modify or interpret existing ones. It already proposes customer disclosure, human assistance and review, meaningful human oversight, and traceability. My response builds on those proposals. It offers a case-level specification and evaluation method from the Necessary Informational Conditions (NIC) research program, and it addresses discussion questions 5C, 7B, 7C, 10A, and 10B.
Four recommendations
- Make the disputed ground discoverable (question 5C). Give the customer a short account identifying the action, its material ground, and a human route for questions, evidence, and disagreement. A person should not first have to diagnose an agent’s hidden error.
- Distinguish explanation, judgment, and power (question 7B). Record the resolution of the objection, the status of the original ground, and the final decision separately. A competent reviewer may explain a documented rationale and examine evidence without the power to rewrite policy.
- Preserve the inquiry, not just the referral (question 7C). Keep a brief case record linking the original action and ground to the objection, evidence, inquiry, authority, response, implemented effects, and open issues. Link existing records instead of copying entire logs.
- Compare routes within the same dispute (questions 10A and 10B). Define the material question and the adequacy standard first. Then compare ordinary-record review, a relevant extract, and reviewer mediation in the same case, with explicit failure conditions.
One application, two disputes
The response works through a hypothetical loan application in two independent versions. Mei Lau receives HKD 24,000 a month in net salary and HKD 6,000 a month under an ongoing services retainer. The product requires HKD 30,000 in eligible monthly income. A bank’s agent classifies her income, applies the product rule, and issues the refusal without case-by-case human approval.
In the first version, the agent makes a mistake. It labels the retainer payments as transfers between Mei’s own accounts and excludes them. The refusal notice names the excluded category, so Mei can say what the payments are. A human reviewer, Alex Chan, reads the statements, payer details, contract, rule, and saved decision account, corrects the classification, and withdraws the refusal ground. Ordinary records answer the objection. Neither Mei nor the reviewer needs a model-internal explanation or a separate calculation extract. The ending keeps three statuses apart: objection resolved; original refusal ground withdrawn; lending decision pending.
In the second version, the agent makes no mistake. A different rule excludes retainers that can be terminated on less than 90 days’ notice, and Mei’s contract permits termination on 30. The calculation is correct. Mei accepts the contract term and asks something else: why does that term make the entire payment count as zero, and how were her three recurring payments considered? The reviewer has the rule but has not obtained a documented rationale that addresses those questions. He requests it from the policy owner and declines to present a possible reason as the bank’s actual one.
Mei: “Then the calculation is checked, but my objection is unanswered.”
Alex: “Yes. The refusal remains in effect. Your policy objection is open.”
The second version ends with the inquiry open: calculation checked; refusal retained; policy justification not yet supplied; objection unresolved. An agent may faithfully implement approved policy while the policy’s justification is contested. Rechecking the sum or exposing model internals would not supply the missing answer. A later answer could reasonably uphold the rule.
Proposed wording
The response offers this wording for consideration.
NIC recommendation, not HKMA text
For a material customer challenge, an institution should be able to show how the customer can identify and investigate the disputed ground and obtain a response addressing it. Where the dispute concerns a governing rule, distinguish its accurate application from its justification. Identify who can explain and examine that justification, who can authorize change, what the customer can still question, and what remains unanswered.
This is an inquiry and accountability design, not a guarantee of favorable judgment.
What the response includes, and what it does not claim
The nine-page response includes the two worked examples, the initial customer notices, the human-review responses, and completed internal review records for both cases. The people, amounts, rules, app routes, and service targets are fictional. The notices and records are NIC proposals, not forms or periods prescribed by the HKMA.
The response reports no bank deployment, participant study, or measured implementation cost. The comparison of information routes it proposes has not been run, and it establishes neither effectiveness nor low cost. The examples review a refusal after it was issued. They do not establish that issuing an automated refusal without prior human approval is an acceptable deployment.
Read the submitted response (PDF, 9 pages)
The response was sent by email to the HKMA’s Banking Supervision Department on November 16, 2026; an acknowledgment has not yet been recorded. I submitted it in my individual capacity. The HKMA invites comments until February 1, 2027, and may publish the comments it receives. See the discussion paper.
The framework is developed in Paper A, From Notice to Contestable Grounds. Related applications include the submitted ICO response, which develops an earlier credit scenario, the French consumer-credit example, and the California employment example, which also separates a correct calculation from a contested rule. The banking cases are fictional and the proposals remain open to empirical scrutiny.