What was proposed
On 11 November 2026 the European Commission adopted a proposal for a Digital Fairness Act, COM(2026) 1100. It would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a regulation and add rules on dark patterns, addictive design, personalised pricing, subscriptions and automated systems that contract on a consumer’s behalf. I read the proposal text for what it lets a person find out. I did not read the annexes or the impact assessment. It is a proposal: Parliament and the Council have not adopted it, and the application date in Article 40 is still a bracket.
Two provisions bear on contestability. Recital 85 recognises that the evidence needed to enforce the rules can sit exclusively with the trader. Article 34 would let courts and authorities order traders to disclose evidence on the design, operation and impact of an online practice, and would let them treat a failure to disclose as relevant to whether the practice is unfair. Article 25 adds a right to reach a human being in post-contract customer service, when other means are not effective.
What I make of it
This part is my reading, not the Commission’s. The disclosure power is the kind of route I look for, and the inference from non-disclosure gives it force. But its trigger is Paper A’s problem in miniature. A court may act when a claimant has presented facts and evidence sufficient to support the likelihood of an unfair practice, or an authority has reasonable suspicion. The person has to have grounds before the evidence route opens, and finding grounds is the step that most needs the evidence.
Article 13 sharpens this. It prohibits harmful personalised pricing where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or vulnerable, and says compliance does not oblige a trader to process more data to find out. What the trader knew is therefore decisive, and it is held by the trader. The authority route may substitute, since it does not depend on one person’s evidence. Whether it does depends on who is placed to see a pattern. Itxaso Domínguez de Olazábal of EDRi, writing on 13 November, argues that the proposal still leaves too much of the burden with consumers, civil society and regulators.
A proposed illustration
This is a hypothetical. A customer who has just lost her job is shown a higher renewal price than a neighbour. She holds one screenshot, her own. A single price proves little. A consumer organisation that had gathered hundreds could meet the threshold in Article 34. Whether she ever reaches that organisation is not something the text addresses.
What the source does not say
In Articles 12 and 13 I found no duty to tell a person that a price was personalised, and in the articles I read no duty to keep records of tested designs or pricing logic. The explanatory memorandum speaks of transparency, and I could not find it in those articles. The annexes may say more. Nor does the text say what counts as reasonable suspicion, or how long any record would survive.
If a court may order the evidence only after someone has shown it probably exists, who is meant to notice first?